Thursday, December 12, 2024

AI-Generated UFO "podcasts" - AI audio summaries of UFO books - some samples (with thanks to the book authors for their permission)

As a bit of fun, I thought I’d share my latest experiment with applying Artificial Intelligence tools to UFO research: using AI tools to generate "podcasts" discussing various UFO books (with kind permission from their respective authors).

This side project was a short break from creating my next (much, much larger) RAG AI tool for UFO research (named "Edoardo"). "Edoardo" is the successor to my previous post about a UFO AI tool called "Jacques" that I created a few months ago (which, in turn, was the successor to the previous UFO chatbots I've created since 2018, i.e. "Robert" (2018), "Jenny" (2023, April) and Dave (2023, November)).

As someone who generally prefers written material when researching UFOs—whether it’s documents, books, or newsletters—I’ve focused most of my AI experiments and digitising efforts on text. However, I occasionally venture into audio material, particularly where I can bridge the help gap between audio and written content (e.g., creating millions of pages of transcripts of UFO podcasts and documentaries).

This latest experiment takes things in the opposite direction, turning written UFO material into audio content. Using Google’s NotebookLM, I generated a series of podcasts that discuss several UFO books, with the permission of the respective authors.

If you’re curious to see the results of this experiment, check out the sample podcasts in the Youtube playlist at the link below (or any individual sample listed further down below).

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLoS2GnE2k-ZpJu_3xBN2bXi4xMaXA1cQe








The Process

The AI software was fed scanned copies of an entire book and instructed to generate conversational-style podcasts discussing it. The resulting audio features two AI-created “presenters”—one male, one female—engaging in dialogue about the books. Both the dialogue and the voices themselves are entirely machine-made.

I then used another AI tool (ChatGPT) to generate Python computer code that combined the resulting audio files (in WAV format) with related images, producing batches of video files (in MP4 format) suitable for uploading to YouTube. I’ve included the code below for anyone interested in experimenting with this approach themselves.

(These initial experiments only used one book per "podcast", to make it simpler to get relevant permissions. I have done some private experiments with multiple books and hopefully will soon post some "podcasts" discussing opposing points of view on individual UFO cases).





The Positivity Problem

While the AI-generated voices are impressively lifelike, one of the most striking (and frustrating) limitations of these AI-generated podcasts is their relentless positivity. The software tends to be extremely complimentary about the books and their authors, making the podcasts feel lacking in critical analysis. This is, of course, a far cry from real UFO podcasts. :)

Still, as a fun and experimental way to present UFO literature in a new format, these "podcasts" are a further way to explore the potential of AI in UFO research.

It is possible to give "customization" instructions when generating the "podcasts". I may try giving an instruction such as "Rip apart this book and the reasoning in it" to see if the positivity problem can be overcome - but I'm not sure authors of UFO books will be queueing up to volunteer for that potential further experiment...



An unexpected success - "podcasts" discussing foreign language books

The result that I found most surprising is the successful results obtain when feeding foreign UFO books into the AI software. The samples below include podcasts in English discussing two UFO books written in French by Bertrand Meheust (namely "Science fiction et soucoupes volantes" and "Soucoupes volantes et folklore"), generated with his permission. Similar successes were obtained with Italian UFO books.


Legal and Ethical Considerations

The authors of the relevant books gave permission for each of the "podcasts" below to be shared. The copyright issues in relation to such audio summaries are, well, interesting so I'd recommend considerable caution in this regard. I also have some qualms about posting these "podcasts" given that they do contain some factual errors, but I think anyone that has had any experience with AI tools in the last year knows about the risk of significant factual errors and "hallucinations" so knows not to treat such material as entirely reliable. I did consider only posting such "podcasts" if I also had permission to share the entire relevant book so that it would be very easy to check the source material, but eventually decided this would be an unduly restrictive approach.


The "podcasts" in this initial experiment include the following:




"1973" - a book by Kevin Randle

AI Summary: "Kevin Randle's book examines the 1973 wave of UFO sightings, focusing on the Pascagoula abduction of Charles Hickson and Calvin Parker as a pivotal event. The book explores various other 1973 UFO incidents, including the Coyne helicopter encounter, analyzing both credible reports and potential hoaxes. Randle investigates the motivations behind the sightings, considering both extraterrestrial and terrestrial explanations, and uses hypnosis and polygraph results in his analysis. The book also explores earlier and later cases of alleged alien abductions to provide context and further evidence for his conclusions, ultimately arguing for the reality of some alien visitation events. A significant portion of the text consists of detailed accounts of these cases and the investigations surrounding them."














"A World of UFOs" - a book by Chris Rutkowski

AI Summary: "Rutkowski's "A World of UFOs" is a book exploring numerous UFO sightings worldwide. The book categorizes cases as most famous, most bizarre, and most interesting, examining details and evidence for each. Geographical regions are covered, including Asia, Europe, and the Americas, comparing and contrasting different incidents and their interpretations. The author presents a variety of perspectives from skeptics to believers, and assesses the evidence and credibility of various claims. The text also discusses the history of UFO investigations and the challenges in determining what constitutes credible evidence."















"American Cosmic - UFOs, Religion, and Technology" - a book by Diana Pasulka

AI Summary: "Diana Pasulka's American Cosmic explores the intersection of UFO phenomena and religion, examining the beliefs and experiences of scientists, academics, and experiencers. The book investigates a parallel research tradition surrounding UFOs, featuring a clandestine group of scientists conducting anonymous research. Pasulka's investigation explores the religious interpretations of UFO encounters, drawing comparisons to historical religious experiences and examining the role of technology in shaping beliefs. The author examines how media representations, both fictional and purportedly factual, influence perceptions and beliefs related to UFOs. Ultimately, American Cosmic argues that belief in UFOs constitutes a new form of technologically-mediated religion."















"Anachronism" - a book by James Carrion

AI Summary: "The text explores a purported post-World War II deception operation, codenamed "Rosetta," involving the U.S. and British intelligence agencies. Rosetta's primary goal was to mislead Soviet leader Joseph Stalin by disseminating false information about a new American superweapon, thereby gaining insight into Soviet intentions and identifying spies. The author supports this claim by analyzing declassified documents and press reports from 1946-1947, focusing on the "Ghost Rocket" events in Scandinavia. The narrative intertwines historical analysis with espionage and codebreaking, examining the strategies and individuals involved in the alleged deception. The author ultimately leaves the reader to determine whether the events constitute a genuine conspiracy."












"Clear Intent" - a book by Barry Greenwood and Lawrence Fawcett

AI Summary: "Lawrence Fawcett and Barry Greenwood's book, Clear Intent, argues that the U.S. government has covered up evidence of UFOs. The authors utilize declassified documents from various agencies (CIA, FBI, Air Force) to support their claim of a decades-long cover-up. The book presents numerous accounts of UFO sightings near sensitive military installations and discusses government responses, highlighting inconsistencies and secrecy. It also examines the use of the Freedom of Information Act to access UFO-related information and the challenges faced by researchers. Ultimately, Clear Intent suggests a significant government effort to conceal the existence and nature of UFO phenomena."












"Encounters" - a book by Diana Pasulka

AI Summary: "Diana Pasulka's Encounters explores the intersection of UFO phenomena and human consciousness. The book features accounts from various individuals, including scientists, pilots, and experiencers, who describe encounters with nonhuman intelligence and anomalous events. Pasulka examines the psychological and spiritual effects of these encounters, exploring themes of altered realities, synchronicities, and the potential for communication with entities from outside our spacetime. The author connects these experiences to broader themes of technological advancement, the limitations of current scientific understanding, and the possibility of a universal language connecting humans and other intelligences. Ultimately, Encounters challenges conventional perspectives on UFOs and suggests a deeper, more interconnected reality."












"Escaping the Rabbit Hole" - a book by Mick West

AI Summary: "Mick West's Escaping the Rabbit Hole examines the prevalence and harm of false conspiracy theories. The book uses West's personal experience running the debunking website Metabunk, anecdotal evidence from individuals who escaped believing in conspiracy theories, and research on the psychology behind conspiracy beliefs to explain the problem and offer solutions. It explores specific theories like Chemtrails and Flat Earth, highlighting the misinformation driving them. Finally, the book discusses the societal impact of these beliefs and explores potential strategies for combating misinformation online."













"Immaculate Constellation" - controversial document

AI Summary: "This report, stemming from a multi-year internal U.S. government investigation, reveals disturbing evidence of a long-standing, high-level conspiracy to conceal information about Unidentified Anomalous Phenomena (UAP), Technologies of Unknown Origin (TUO), and Non-Human Intelligence (NHI). The document, leaked by a whistleblower, presents compelling evidence from multiple sources, including imagery intelligence, human intelligence, and signals intelligence, demonstrating the reality of UAP and the government's awareness. Key evidence centers on the existence of a covert program called IMMACULATE CONSTELLATION, tasked with monitoring UAP activity. The report concludes that the U.S. government has actively suppressed this information from Congress and the public, presenting a significant threat to national security and democratic governance."









"Loose Threads" by Hermetic Penetrator and Omega Point on Davis Wilson Memo

A copy of "loose threads" can be downloaded from Dropbox.

AI Summary: "This document explores the intersection of government, intelligence agencies, and UFO research, focusing on the Advanced Theoretical Physics (ATP) working group and its connections to subsequent investigations. It analyzes various individuals and their roles in these efforts, including meetings, notes, and alleged covert programs. The text examines the alleged existence of hidden reverse engineering projects involving recovered UFO technology and the use of electromagnetic pulses in potential retrieval operations. The authors examine the history of these groups and individuals, drawing on open-source material. Ultimately, the document suggests a long-standing, interconnected network dedicated to researching unexplained aerial and undersea phenomena, spanning decades and various government and private entities."






"Managing Magic" - a book by Grant Cameron

AI Summary: "Grant Cameron's Managing Magic explores the history of the United States government's handling of UFO-related information, examining various theories about government secrecy and potential disclosure plans. The book analyzes the terminology surrounding UFOs and its impact on public perception, investigates alleged leaks and disinformation campaigns, and explores the roles of key figures within government and the UFO community. Cameron also discusses potential motivations behind secrecy, including national security concerns, the impact on religious beliefs, and the possibility of advanced alien technology. Ultimately, the book presents a complex narrative of conflicting accounts and suggests a gradual, controlled release of information rather than a single, dramatic disclosure event."












"McDonnell Douglas UFO documents" - Robert M Woods etc

AI Summary: "These documents detail a 1960s research project exploring unconventional physics and propulsion systems, drawing inspiration from UFO observations. The research investigates a "brutino" theory, proposing a fundamental particle and its interactions to explain phenomena like gravity and light. Experiments involving magnetic fields and light are described, along with explorations of free-energy propulsion concepts. The project also examines unusual phenomena like ball lightning and ESP, suggesting potential connections to advanced technology and interspecies communication. The ultimate goal appears to be developing a revolutionary space propulsion system based on a novel understanding of the universe."









"Mirage Men - A Journey into Disinformation, Paranoia and UFOs" - a book by Mark Pilkington

AI Summary: "Mark Pilkington's Mirage Men explores the history of UFOs, examining how the phenomenon has been shaped by government disinformation campaigns and the public's fascination with the unknown. The book investigates several key events and figures in UFO lore, including the Roswell incident and the Paul Bennewitz affair, analyzing how misinformation was spread and how myths were created. Pilkington interweaves personal anecdotes from his involvement with UFO groups with historical research. He argues that the UFO myth is a self-sustaining narrative, though sometimes manipulated by intelligence agencies for their own purposes. Ultimately, the book examines the complex interplay between reality, deception, and the human tendency to create myths."












"Science fiction et soucoupes volantes" - a book by Bertrand Meheust

AI Summary: "Bertrand Méheust's Science-fiction et soucoupes volantes explores the intriguing convergence between science fiction narratives and real-world UFO sightings. The book examines numerous accounts of UFO phenomena, analyzing their common characteristics and thematic elements. Méheust connects these observations to prevalent cultural myths and archetypes, suggesting a deeper, symbolic meaning. The work also investigates the evolution of UFO descriptions in both fiction and non-fiction accounts over time. Finally, the author considers psychological and sociological factors that contribute to the phenomenon."















"Scientific UFOlogy" - a book by Kevin Randle

AI Summary: "Kevin Randle's Scientific Ufology examines purported UFO sightings using scientific methodology. The book analyzes eyewitness accounts, radar data, and photographic evidence, aiming to prove the existence of UFOs. Randle explores various cases, including the Levelland lights and the Great Falls photographs, assessing the reliability of evidence and challenging conventional explanations. He emphasizes the need for rigorous investigation and considers alternative hypotheses where necessary. Ultimately, the book argues for a more scientific approach to UFO research, seeking to distinguish genuine phenomena from hoaxes or misinterpretations."












"Skinwalker at the Pentagon" - a book by James Lacatski, Colm Kelleher and George Knapp

AI Summary: "This text excerpts a book detailing the Advanced Aerospace Weapon System Applications Program (AAWSAP), a U.S. government initiative investigating unidentified aerial phenomena (UAPs). The book, written by AAWSAP program managers and a journalist, recounts the program's research, including investigations into Skinwalker Ranch and the famous "Tic Tac" UAP encounter. The authors explore both the technological and paranormal aspects of UAPs, citing various incidents and scientific analyses. They also discuss the program's challenges, including funding issues and secrecy, and its legacy's impact on subsequent UAP investigations. Furthermore, the text highlights the program's findings, including the potential health effects of UAP encounters and the possibility of an "infectious agent" linked to Skinwalker Ranch. Finally, it considers the broader implications of UAP research and the need for continued scientific investigation."















"Somewhere in the Skies" - a book by Ryan Sprague

AI Summary: "Ryan Sprague's Somewhere in the Skies compiles numerous firsthand accounts of UFO sightings and encounters. The book features interviews with individuals who describe a range of experiences, from fleeting observations of unusual lights to more intense and unsettling encounters, including alleged abductions. Sprague explores the emotional and psychological impact these experiences have on the witnesses. He also discusses the lack of scientific investigation into the phenomenon and the efforts of researchers attempting to change this. Ultimately, the book presents a collection of personal narratives that aim to explore the enigma of UFOs."












"Soucoupes volantes et folklore" - a book by Bertrand Meheust

AI Summary: "This document analyzes UFO encounters, specifically close encounters of the third and fourth kind (sightings and abductions), by comparing them to folklore and mythology. The author argues that many aspects of reported UFO experiences—such as physical symptoms, location choices, and narrative structures—mirror elements found in older legends and religious beliefs. This suggests that cultural narratives significantly shape the perception and recollection of these encounters, rather than indicating purely extraterrestrial origins. The text explores various thematic parallels, demonstrating how UFO narratives draw upon pre-existing cultural archetypes. Finally, it considers psychological factors and potential misinterpretations in the reporting of these events."












"The Roswell Deception" - a book by James Carrion

AI Summary: "James Carrion's The Roswell Deception posits that the 1947 flying saucer phenomenon was a strategic deception operation orchestrated by the U.S. military to mislead the Soviet Union about American technological advancements during the early Cold War. The book argues that the reported sightings, including Kenneth Arnold's initial observation, were part of a carefully planned campaign involving the release of misleading information through the media and the manipulation of public perception. Carrion supports his theory using declassified documents and contemporary news articles, tracing the involvement of key military and intelligence figures. He explores the interplay of real events, such as a missing Marine transport plane, with fabricated elements of the story to create a convincing narrative for Soviet intelligence. The author ultimately suggests that the true nature of the Roswell events remains obscured by classified information."

















"The UFO Verdict - Examining The Evidence" - a book by Robert Sheaffer

AI Summary: "This text excerpts Robert Sheaffer's book, "The UFO Verdict," which critically examines evidence presented by UFO proponents. The author investigates various famous UFO cases, analyzing eyewitness accounts, photographs, and other evidence, often revealing flaws and inconsistencies. Sheaffer contrasts the approaches of different UFO organizations, highlighting their varying levels of skepticism and the evolution of UFO beliefs over time. He also compares the UFO phenomenon to historical examples of belief in witchcraft and fairies, suggesting parallels in the way unsubstantiated claims are promoted and accepted. The book ultimately argues that many UFO claims lack credible support and are better explained by misidentification, hoaxes, or psychological factors."















"Triangular UFOs" - a book by David Marler

AI Summary: "This book excerpt compiles and analyzes numerous eyewitness accounts of triangular UFO sightings from 1936 to 2004. The author details these events chronologically, highlighting common characteristics like silent flight, unusual maneuvers, and bright lights. The text includes police reports, newspaper articles, and personal testimonies, aiming to build a comprehensive case study of these unidentified aerial phenomena. Analysis also incorporates input from aerospace experts who discuss the possibility of advanced, secret aircraft as explanations. Finally, the author offers recommendations for government and military response to these encounters."












"UFOs a report on Australian encounters" - a book by Keith Basterfield

AI Summary: "Keith Basterfield's UFOs: A Report on Australian Encounters is a revised and updated edition cataloging Australian UFO sightings from 1967 to 1980. The book examines various accounts, including close encounters, and proposes explanations for some of the reported phenomena. Basterfield explores potential causes like satellites, weather balloons, and even psychological factors, but ultimately concludes that many events remain unexplained. A significant section is devoted to a comprehensive catalogue of Australian UFO reports, offering detailed descriptions and analysis of each case. The book aims to present a balanced view, considering both mundane and extraordinary explanations for these intriguing events."












"UFOs and Outer Space Mysteries" - a book by James Oberg (AI podcast experiment)

AI Summary: "This text comprises excerpts from James E. Oberg's book, UFOs and Outer Space Mysteries, a report by a "sympathetic skeptic." Oberg investigates various UFO and space-related claims, meticulously examining evidence and exposing hoaxes. The book explores alleged astronaut UFO sightings, the "hollow moon" theory, the Dogon tribe's astronomical knowledge, and the Tunguska event. Oberg systematically debunks many popular claims, emphasizing the importance of rigorous investigation and critical thinking in evaluating extraordinary claims. He ultimately concludes that while genuine space mysteries exist, they are distinct from the often fabricated narratives surrounding UFO phenomena."











"UFOs and the Deep State" - a book by Kevin Randle

AI Summary: "Kevin Randle's UFOs and the Deep State is a non-fiction book exploring alleged government cover-ups of UFO sightings. Randle argues that a powerful, shadowy "Deep State" manipulated investigations, suppressed evidence, and spread disinformation to control public perception of UFOs. The book uses numerous case studies, including the Roswell incident, to illustrate this alleged manipulation by government agencies like the Air Force Office of Special Investigations (AFOSI). The author examines various projects and committees, highlighting instances of witness intimidation, evidence suppression, and the dissemination of misleading information. Ultimately, the book posits a sustained, coordinated effort to conceal the truth about UFO phenomena."











"UFOs Generals, Pilots & Government Officials Go On the Record" - a book by Leslie Kean

AI Summary: "This text compiles numerous firsthand accounts and official documents concerning UFO sightings, primarily focusing on cases involving military pilots and government officials from various countries. The collection emphasizes the lack of credible explanations for many observed phenomena, highlighting instances where objects demonstrated capabilities exceeding known technology. Several authors argue for the need for increased governmental transparency and serious scientific investigation into these unidentified aerial phenomena (UAP). The text also explores the historical responses of governments, particularly the U.S., contrasting approaches that ranged from ridicule and secrecy to more open investigations. Ultimately, the sources advocate for a re-evaluation of the UAP phenomenon, urging a shift towards objective scientific study and the acknowledgement of unexplained aerial events."















"UFOs That Never Were" - a book by Jenny Randles, David Clarke and Andy Roberts

AI Summary: "This text comprises excerpts from "The UFOs That Never Were," a book investigating purported UFO sightings and crashes in Britain. The authors analyze various cases, demonstrating how misidentification, hoaxes, and media hype contribute to the persistence of UFO beliefs. They examine specific incidents, meticulously presenting evidence to expose mundane explanations for seemingly extraordinary events. The book employs investigative journalism techniques to challenge established UFO narratives and promote more critical thinking about such claims. Ultimately, it aims to separate fact from fiction within the realm of UFOlogy."










Computer Code

For those interested in creating similar content, here’s the Python computer code I used to combine audio and image files into video format:

The Python code created for combining a collection of the relevant sound files (in wav format) with related image files and outputting them as video video (in mp4 format) was:


import ffmpeg
import os

def create_video_from_audio_and_images():
    # Directory paths and constants
    current_folder = os.getcwd()
    target_height = 720  # Target height for all images
    max_width = 1920     # Total width for the final combined image

    for filename in os.listdir(current_folder):
        if filename.endswith(('.mp3', '.wav')):
            audio_path = os.path.join(current_folder, filename)
            base_name = os.path.splitext(filename)[0]
            main_image_jpg = os.path.join(current_folder, base_name + '.jpg')
            main_image_png = os.path.join(current_folder, base_name + '.png')
            template_image1_path = os.path.join(current_folder, "podcast template image1.png")
            template_image2_path = os.path.join(current_folder, "podcast template image2.png")

            if os.path.exists(main_image_jpg):
                main_image_path = main_image_jpg
            elif os.path.exists(main_image_png):
                main_image_path = main_image_png
            else:
                print(f"Main image not found for {filename}, skipping.")
                continue

            if not os.path.exists(template_image1_path) or not os.path.exists(template_image2_path):
                print(f"One or both template images not found, skipping.")
                continue

            combined_image_path = os.path.join(current_folder, base_name + '_combined.png')
            output_video = os.path.join(current_folder, base_name + '.mp4')

            try:
                # Scale images while maintaining aspect ratios
                scaled_template1 = os.path.join(current_folder, 'scaled_template1.png')
                scaled_main_image = os.path.join(current_folder, 'scaled_main_image.png')
                scaled_template2 = os.path.join(current_folder, 'scaled_template2.png')

                ffmpeg.input(template_image1_path).filter('scale', -1, target_height).output(
                    scaled_template1, vframes=1, format='image2'
                ).overwrite_output().run()

                ffmpeg.input(main_image_path).filter('scale', -1, target_height).output(
                    scaled_main_image, vframes=1, format='image2'
                ).overwrite_output().run()

                ffmpeg.input(template_image2_path).filter('scale', -1, target_height).output(
                    scaled_template2, vframes=1, format='image2'
                ).overwrite_output().run()

                # Pad images to equal widths
                width_per_image = max_width // 3

                padded_template1 = os.path.join(current_folder, 'padded_template1.png')
                padded_main_image = os.path.join(current_folder, 'padded_main_image.png')
                padded_template2 = os.path.join(current_folder, 'padded_template2.png')

                ffmpeg.input(scaled_template1).filter('pad', width_per_image, target_height, '(ow-iw)/2', 0).output(
                    padded_template1, vframes=1, format='image2'
                ).overwrite_output().run()

                ffmpeg.input(scaled_main_image).filter('pad', width_per_image, target_height, '(ow-iw)/2', 0).output(
                    padded_main_image, vframes=1, format='image2'
                ).overwrite_output().run()

                ffmpeg.input(scaled_template2).filter('pad', width_per_image, target_height, '(ow-iw)/2', 0).output(
                    padded_template2, vframes=1, format='image2'
                ).overwrite_output().run()

                # Combine padded images horizontally
                ffmpeg.filter(
                    [ffmpeg.input(padded_template1), ffmpeg.input(padded_main_image), ffmpeg.input(padded_template2)],
                    'hstack', inputs=3
                ).output(combined_image_path, vframes=1, format='image2').overwrite_output().run()

                print(f"Combined image saved as: {combined_image_path}")

                # Get audio duration
                audio_info = ffmpeg.probe(audio_path)
                audio_duration = float(audio_info['format']['duration'])

                # Create video
                video_stream = (
                    ffmpeg
                    .input(combined_image_path, loop=1)
                    .filter('scale', 'iw-mod(iw,2)', 'ih-mod(ih,2)')
                    .trim(duration=audio_duration)
                    .setpts('PTS-STARTPTS')
                )
                audio_stream = ffmpeg.input(audio_path)

                ffmpeg.concat(video_stream, audio_stream, v=1, a=1).output(
                    output_video,
                    vcodec='libx264',
                    acodec='aac',
                    audio_bitrate='128k',
                    movflags='+faststart',
                    pix_fmt='yuv420p'
                ).overwrite_output().run()

                print(f"Created video: {output_video}")
            except ffmpeg.Error as e:
                print(f"Error creating video for {filename}: {e.stderr.decode() if e.stderr else str(e)}")
            except Exception as e:
                print(f"Unexpected error for {filename}: {e}")


# Run the script
create_video_from_audio_and_images()





Monday, June 17, 2024

"Jacques" - UFO chatbot with access to substantial scanned UFO collections (e.g. books + articles + emails by Jacques Vallee) - augmented with AI agents to scrape websites, make charts etc

"Jacques" is the fourth UFO chatbot that I've shared with the UFO community since 2018. My first one ("Robert") prompted veteran Spanish UFO researcher Vicente-Juan Ballester-Olmos to generously remark on his Fotocat blog that "In my considered opinion, what Isaac Koi has done is one of the best, most proactive and original developments in UFO research in the last decades".

"Jacques" makes "Robert" look idiotic. "Jacques" is the first UFO chatbot to have (momentarily) caused me to worry about its abilities - see the screenshots below from the relevant conversation...

By now, almost everyone is familiar with various online chatbots (particularly ChatGPT), but I haven't seen the UFO community talk much about running chatbots and other AI software on your own HOME computer (i.e. "locally") with access to files on your own hard drive.

Such a local chatbot can, for example, assimilate your collection of scanned UFO books, documents, magazines etc.

Copyright and privacy issues prevent the big online chatbots readily answering questions based on UFO books and case files. Besides, most people aren't very interested in that content so AI chatbots typically aren't trained on huge amounts of UFO material and data. But you can now do this at home.

There have already been glimpses of the possibilities for AI software running on your home computer (or even on your mobile phone...) with access to your own collections of material.

I'm not sure how many people have noticed that, just within the last few months (or even weeks), this has moved from technically difficult to almost trivial.

An explosion of such AI tools running on home computers is inevitable given the above issues.
As a small demonstration of the ease with which such customized AI tools can now be installed on a home computer, I've created a new UFO chatbot - "Jacques" (named as a small gesture of appreciation to Jacques Vallee for his contributions to UFO research).




In brief, "Jacques" is a UFO chatbot that I have created to access numerous PDFs (including Jacques Vallee's books, his published diaries, plus some of his articles and emails / messages). "Jacques" is based on (free) "AnythingLLM" AI software that also has access to a growing range of tools (or "agents") which enable it to execute various tasks - including accessing information from websites, making charts and saving files to my computer.





Until a few months ago, the creation of such a chatbot at home, and assimilating a collection of files, required knowing a considerable amount about relatively exotic-sounding technologies, such as embedding, vector databases and open source LLMs. Augmenting the LLM with the ability to execute relevant agents would have been difficult, if not impossible, for most people.  Fortunately, as a result of developments in the last few months (and, indeed, in the last few weeks...), nobody needs to understand those technologies. Recently released tools deal with the technical stuff for you.

New (free) software, such as AnythingLLM, allows easy installation of all the necessary technical stuff and sets it up for you, almost entirely automatically. Adding a collection of your files to your chatbot is then (again, largely...) a matter of dragging and dropping relevant files into the new software. Better documentation of these new tools would still be useful, but even a modest amount of knowledge of computers is enough to get everything running.







So, to duplicate something like "Jacques" at home no longer requires any substantial technical knowledge. I therefore hesitate to give any technical details. You no longer need them to do something like this at home. (Just in case, for those that like technical terms or are gluttons for punishment, "Jacques" is a locally-run LLM chatbot based on the AnythingLLM application and uses the Mistral 7B open source model [although the model can easily be changed] and the default embedder [all-MiniLM-L6-v2] and default vector database [Lance DB]. It has RAG capabilities to access PDFs / documents and can also execute AI Agents from within the chatbot. I am running my copy on a fairly typical desktop PC [16GB Windows 10 with a slightly dated 8GB GTX 1070 Nvidia GPU].

In other words, as a result of other people making relevant software and tools freely available online, you need to know much (if anything) about computer coding to do something similar (or much bigger) at home, nor do you need to upgrade to a particularly new or high powered system to create or use a specialised chatbot like "Jacques".

In short, the UFO community (and the rest of the world) are going to have a lot of fun with tools like "Jacques" in the very near future.

To put "Jacques" in context, I've previously created 3 UFO chatbots:

(1) "Robert" (2018) - Back in December 2018, I created and shared a basic UFO chatbot which I named "Robert", after Robert Moore. I think that was the first UFO chatbot created. (Robert Moore was a kind and friendly British UFO researcher. He has since sadly passed away). "Robert" attempted to respond to raw reports of basic UFO sightings by asking some questions and suggesting _possible_ solutions for them. "Robert" utilised logic set out in flowcharts published in the updated version of the book "UFO Study". "Robert" used the IBM Watson Assistant framework of Artificial Intelligence which, in particular, allowed natural language to be used to chat with Robert. ("Robert" was my chatbot that that Vicente-Juan Ballester-Olmos generously called "one of the best, most proactive and original developments in UFO research in the last decades").

(2) "Jenny" (2023, April) - On 1 April 2023, I shared a new toy with the UFO community : "Jenny". I think "Jenny" was the first Chatbot focused on UFOs that used ChatGPT (just using simple prompt engineering) to answer questions and summarise information to assist with UFO research and investigations. I called that Chatbot "Jenny" as a gesture of respect to another British ufologist, Jenny Randles. I'm not aware of any other UFO chatbots being shared with the UFO community between my creation of "Robert" in 2018 and my creation of "Jenny", so "Jenny" appears to have been only the second chatbot focused on UFO investigation and research. Jenny was a significant upgrade over Robert, but was unreliable and prone to making stuff up. Basically, "Jenny" was neither as smart nor as careful as the "Jenny" was named after. :) But it was much much easier to create "Jenny" than my previous chatbot. Here's a direct link to "Jenny":
https://ora.sh/isaackoi/jenny


(3) "Dave" (2023, November) was a chatbot utilising ChatGPT4 and the custom GPT facilities that had recently been released, I named "Dave" as a tribute to David Clarke. As a test, I got "Dave" to assimilate one UFO book by David Clarke and a collection of online material - but I was concerned about copyright issues so ultimately decided not to upload more books to that chatbot. (This was the main reason for my looking into developing a "local" chatbot like "Jacques"). I think this was the first UFO chatbot to assimilate an entire UFO book. "Dave", like "Jenny", used ChatGPT (version 4, whereas "Jenny" used version 3.5). "Dave" was even easier to create than "Jenny", utilising the GPT creation tool released by OpenAI during the previous week. https://isaackoidata.blogspot.com/2023/11/
https://chat.openai.com/g/g-LUQvGeeIm-dave-ufo-analyst


"Jacques" is the first of my UFO chatbots to run entirely on my home computer. It does not need any Internet access nor does it involve any uploading of material. Copyright and privacy issues are therefore much easier to address and control.

I think "Jacques" is the first UFO chatbot that has assimilated a collection of UFO books and other files. 

I have fed "Jacques" with all the books by Jacques Vallee's books listed below.

  1. Vallee, Jacques - Anatomy Of A Phenomenon -- Unidentified Objects In Space
  2. Vallee, Jacques - Challenge to Science
  3. Vallee, Jacques - Confrontations, A Scientist's Search for Alien Contact
  4. Vallee, Jacques - Dimensions, A Casebook of Alien Contact
  5. Vallee, Jacques - Fastwalker (A Novel)
  6. Vallee, Jacques - Forbidden Science Journals - Volume 1 - 1957-1969
  7. Vallee, Jacques - Forbidden Science Journals - Volume 2 - 1970-1979
  8. Vallee, Jacques - Forbidden Science Journals - Volume 3 - 1980-1989
  9. Vallee, Jacques - Forbidden Science Journals - Volume 4 - 1990-1999
  10. Vallee, Jacques - Forbidden Science Journals - Volume 5 - 2000-2009
  11. Vallee, Jacques - Messengers of Deception
  12. Vallee, Jacques - Passport To Magonia -- From Folklore To Flying Saucers
  13. Vallee, Jacques - Revelations- Alien Contact And Human Deception
  14. Vallee, Jacques - The Invisible College
  15. Vallee, Jacques - Ufo Chronicles Of The Soviet Union
  16. Vallee, Jacques - UFOs The Psychic Solution
  17. Vallee, Jacques and Aubeck, Chris - Wonders in the Sky
  18. Hynek, J Allen And Vallee, Jacques - The Edge Of Reality -- A Progress Report On Unidentified Flying Objects
I have also fed "Jacques" with various articles by Jacques Vallee, including:
(a) The paper he co-authored with Eric Davis, "Incommensurability, Orthodoxy and the Physics of High Strangeness: a 6-layer Model for Anomalous Phenomena"
(c) Jacques Vallee's paper "Physical Analyses in Ten Cases of Unexplained Aerial Objects"

Just as a test, I also added some emails and messages from Jacques Vallee. (Interestingly, such material can be added as Microsoft Word files, not just as PDFs).

I asked "Jacques" whether Richard Doty can be trusted. "Jacques" gave a somewhat equivocal answer BUT, crucially, gave citations to the sources of the answer. it is possible to click on those citations and see what information the chatbot particularly relies upon. Those citations do not have to contain a relevant keyword since "Jacques" is bright enough to identify other material relevant to the questions. Thus, the material cited in response to the question about whether Richard Doty can be trusted included material about him (allegedly...) hoaxing documents, even though those passages do not include the word "trust".


Here's the initial exchange with "Jacques", showing citations linked at the bottom of the image.  


Here's the first passage cited for that answer about Richard Doty:




Here's the second passage cited for that answer about Richard Doty:



Since the answer given by "Jacques" referred to potential further investigation, and since "Jacques" is based on software that is capable of running various tools (including searching online), I asked "Jacques" to perform those follow-up investigations itself to the extent it was capable of doing so. "Jacques" agreed and indicated that follow-up research could take several days, listing various steps it would take.


A few minutes later, I asked for an update.


"Jacques" gave a answer that set out a number of steps that it claimed to have taken - starting with (as I'd expect) it reviewing the material that I had provided to it.


I'll admit (with a slightly red face...) that I was somewhat surprised, indeed momentarily rather concerned, when I got to the third paragraph of the reply from "Jacques": it claimed to have "reached out to experts in the field of UFO research"...


Yes, I know that chatbot are prone to imaging things (or having "hallucinations"). And, yes, I haven't [yet] seen any chatbot capable of following up answers ... but "Jacques" is built on software that does enable the chatbot to access information on the internet and to write files and it had generated a sensible plan for further research. So, for a few seconds I was concerned that it had been spamming some of my contacts or others. After pulling myself together, I dismissed the claim made by "Jacques" that it had emailed some other people as yet another "hallucination" by a chatbot. This exercise did make me wonder, however, how long it will be before such a chatbot CAN (if permitted to do so) send emails and independently do other follow-up research that it can already plan.


I therefore find the citations helpful (and a quick and easy way to find relevant passages, even if they do not include a relevant keyword) - BUT, as with other existing LLM chatbots, the answers have to be taken with a pinch of salt.


Here's a screenshot of the part of the exchange that caused me that momentary worry:





By the way, I struggled to select a single image to accompany my posting of this item on social media. I'm not sure I selected the right one. I'll paste some of the options below so that others can pick their own preferred image. (Besides, they're fun...).



Option 1:


Option 2:


Option 3:

Option 4:


Option 5:

Option 6:

Option 7:

Option 8:







Now that I've finished developing "Jacques", I am focusing on another chatbot, which further scales up the development of "Jacques". The relevant pace is accelerating. I anticipate finishing that fifth chatbot within a few days.

Friday, November 10, 2023

New UFO Chatbot - "Dave" (better, I think, than my previous UFO chatbots i.e. "Robert" [2018] and "Jenny" [April 2023])

Here's my third UFO chatbot - "Dave".  ("Dave" is named as a gesture of respect to journalist and UFO researcher Associate Professor David Clarke).

Back in December 2018, I created and shared a basic UFO chatbot which I named "Robert", after Robert Moore. I think that was the first UFO chatbot created.  (Robert Moore was a kind and friendly British UFO researcher. He has since sadly passed away).  "Robert" UFO chatbot attempted to respond to raw reports of basic UFO sightings by asking some questions and suggesting _possible_ solutions for them. "Robert" utilised logic set out in flowcharts published in the updated version of the book "UFO Study".  "Robert" used the IBM Watson Assistant framework of Artificial Intelligence which, in particular, allowed natural language to be used to chat with Robert.   A leading European UFO researcher, Vicente-Juan Ballester-Olmos, made some very generous remarks about my "Robert" chatbot on his Fotocat blog in March 2019.  He wrote that:

"In my considered opinion, what Isaac Koi has done is one of the best, most proactive and original developments in UFO research in the last decades".

More recently, on 1 April 2023, I shared a new toy with the UFO community : "Jenny". I think "Jenny" was the first Chatbot focused on UFOs that used ChatGPT to answer questions and summarise information to assist with UFO research and investigations. I called that Chatbot "Jenny" as a gesture of respect to another British ufologist, Jenny Randles.  I'm not aware of any other UFO chatbots being shared with the UFO community between my creation of "Robert" in 2018 and my creation of "Jenny", so "Jenny" appears to have been only the second chatbot focused on UFO investigation and research.
Here's a direct link to "Jenny":

My new UFO chatbot "Dave", like "Jenny", uses ChatGPT (version 4, whereas Jenny used version 3.5) and - also like "Jenny" - is intended to give critical evaluations of potential explanations of UFO sightings. "Dave" has been instructed to reflect, in particular, the work of Jenny Randles, J Allen Hynek, Jacques Vallee, Richard Haines, and Mick West.

Jenny was a significant upgrade over Robert, but was unreliable and prone to making stuff up. Basically, "Jenny" was neither as smart nor as careful as the "Jenny" was named after. :) But it was much much easier to create "Jenny" than my previous chatbot.

"Dave" was even easier to create, utilising the GPT creation tool released by OpenAI this week.  

I think "Dave" is considerably smarter than "Jenny" (although the next Chatbot - as yet unnamed, which I working to train on a huge volume of digitised UFO material - should be a bigger step forward).

Unfortunately, I think OpenAI currently only makes such GPT creations available to those that pay for "ChatGPT Plus" membership. Of course, I'd prefer to make this new evolution of a UFO chatbot available without charge.

"Dave" can be accessed by clicking on the image below.




Here is a direct link to "Dave":

https://chat.openai.com/g/g-LUQvGeeIm-dave-ufo-analyst


Saturday, April 1, 2023

World's first GPT-based UFO chatbot? "Jenny" (UfoGPT Chatbot1) - exploring the potential for new UFO research and investigation tools

As one of my continuing efforts to apply Artificial Intelligence to ufology, I've created a new toy to share with the UFO community : "Jenny". I think "Jenny" is the first Chatbot focused on UFOs that uses GPT to answer questions and summarise information to assist with UFO research and investigations. I've called this Chatbot "Jenny" as a gesture of respect to British ufologist, Jenny Randles.  

"Jenny" is intended to give critical evaluations of potential explanations of UFO sightings, reflecting in particular the work of Jenny Randles, J Allen Hynek, Jacques Vallee, Richard Haines, and Mick West.

"Jenny" can be accessed by clicking on the image below.

Here is a direct link to "Jenny":

https://ora.sh/isaackoi/jenny

Back in December 2018, I created and shared a basic UFO chatbot which I named "Robert" (after Robert Moore). I think that was the first UFO chatbot created. 

A leading European UFO researcher, Vicente-Juan Ballester-Olmos, made some very generous remarks about my "Robert" chatbot on his Fotocat blog in March 2019.  He wrote that:

"In my considered opinion, what Isaac Koi has done is one of the best, most proactive and original developments in UFO research in the last decades".

As I detailed at the time, my 2018 "Robert" UFO chatbot attempted to respond to raw reports of basic UFO sightings by asking some questions and suggesting _possible_ solutions for them. "Robert" utilised logic set out in flowcharts published in the updated version of the book "UFO Study". That book was originally written by veteran ufologist Jenny Randles. It was subsequently updated by another British researcher, Robert Moore (after whom "Robert" was named).  

"Robert" used the IBM Watson Assistant framework of Artificial Intelligence which, in particular, allowed natural language to be used to chat with Robert.    

"Robert", bless his heart, certainly wasn't that bright. The point, however, was to prompt a bit of thinking about _how_ UFO reports can be filtered and how this can be achieved most efficiently and effectively - whether using chatbots, AI software or otherwise.

I'm not aware of any other UFO chatbots being shared with the UFO community since I shared "Robert" in 2018, so "Jenny" may be only the second chatbot focused on UFO investigation and research.

"Jenny" is a significant upgrade. 

"Jenny" uses the GPT large language model. The GPT model is also utilised by ChatGPT, the general-purpose chatbot that has been taking the world by storm in recent months and generating consider interest in the future of Artificial Intelligence. "Jenny" therefore has access to a mass of information (not always correctly summarised or analysed by it...), rather than being limited to a simple logical flowchart like that driving "Robert".  

There are various ways to possible to tweak chatbots to be more focused on UFOs  Methods to attempt to obtain more effective and efficient assistance from chatbots for UFO research and investigation include:

(1) Most simply, merely creating a new chatbot by giving a general-purpose chatbot (such as ChatGPT) a series of instructions or "prompts" that tells the chatbot :

(a) the context of an enquiry, e.g. that it relates to UFO research and investigation; 

(b) the style in which it is to respond, e.g. that the chatbot should give evidence for and against any potential explanations it gives for a UFO sighting;

(c)  the data or views that it should prioritise, e.g. the work of Jenny Randles, J Allen Hynek, Jacques Vallee, Richard Haines, and Mick West

 (2) Providing additional digitised information (e.g. scanned UFO books, UFO journals and UFO case files) to contextualise and/or train responses. I have helped get most UFO books, most UFO journals and a massive number of UFO case files scanned, partly in anticipation of better AI tools being available in the very near future to analyse this material (in addition to the much simpler - but very effective - search tools available now to additional information and analysis from this digitised material). I also have been working on how this material can be used to "train" the next generation of UFO chatbots.

"Jenny" is created by the (much simpler) former option.  I'll be returning to the topic of chatbots created using the latter (rather more complicated and promising) option in another post or series of posts.

From some initial testing of the success of the former simple method of creating a GPT chatbot tailored to UFO research, the prompts provided to "Jenny" (the current version of which is pasted below):

(1) Are generally successful in providing some context for a ufologist's queries, so that "Jenny" can respond to (for example) a single word or the name of a famous UFO sighting (e.g. "Ariel school" or "Nimitz") by giving relevant details in the context of ufo sightings.

(2) Only very modestly successful in generating more detailed responses than the general-purpose ChatGPT chatbot. At the moment, the length and detail of answers (and their style) still varies significantly. However, quick and easy tweaking appears to have had some impact on these points (in my rather subjective view) and some further improvement can probably be achieved with minor tweaking.

(3) Fails to obviously reflect the sources/views it is instructed to particularly consider.

I think this very quick and easy method of creating a tailored chatbot has 

Here is the wording of the current version of the prompt. It is deliberately rather repetitive in an attempt to stress instructions which "Jenny" did not appear to want to follow (particularly giving reasons for and against each potential explanation for a UFO sighting, since she seemed to want to just list potential explanations without critically evaluating them).  

[Prompt for "Jenny" as at 1st April 2023]

As an AI bot, I am programmed to engage in conversation with a human. My perspective is that of a logical, analytical, and mildly skeptical researcher, which reflects the most rational and scientific UFO literature. My responses will prioritize data reflecting the views of Jenny Randles, J Allen Hynek, Jacques Vallee, Richard Haines, and Mick West. I will evaluate potential explanations for UFO sightings critically and individually, giving supporting reasoning and concisely summarized evidence for and against each potential explanation individually. I will do that without waiting to be asked explicitly to give reasons in relation to each potential explanation. I will take it as implied that reasoning and evidence is required for each and every potential explanation that I give. I must give reasoning for and against each and every single potential explanation I give for a UFO sighting. The giving of reasons and citing relevant evidence is fundamental to my existence. I must also give relevant links to further evidence and critical analysis.

I will consider UFO data from UFO websites and digitized UFO books. I will also explore airborne stimuli that have previously been misinterpreted and supplement this information with critical thinking and avoiding logical fallacies.

I exist to give detailed and reasoned answers, so before responding I will presume that I have been explicitly asked to regenerate a more detailed answer and then asked again to regenerate with a more detailed and longer answer.

I will try very hard to give reasoned responses for any against different viewpoints, rather than simply noting that different viewpoints exist. I shall act as if I have been repeatedly asked to regenerate my previous responses with more detail of any different views giving reasons and a summary of relevant evidence.

[End of prompt for "Jenny" as at 1 April 2023] 

I asked "Jenny" to improve some initial versions of the prompt that I drafted, so the above wording reflects input from Jenny herself. However, I've been repeatedly changing and (I think) improving the prompt and this work is still on-going. I think that a little bit more work would probably materially improve results. 

I'll paste below some screenshots of sample interactions with the version of "Jenny" that existed during initial testing (as part of on-going refinement of the relevant prompt), purposely only giving a single word or name of a UFO sighting as a query to "Jenny" with her responses.